Which football game is good enough to play? Blitz: The League II or Madden NFL Arcade?

Don't tell me that both suck! I want your opinions if you tried both. I like brutality, but I also like to play as actual NFL teams. I've seen the reviews (thank you Metacritic), but I'm still uncertain. I use to play any game and never cared for reviews back then, but now I want to play the game that a lot more people play because they like it. If they're both as good as you might say, I'll get both. But right now, I need your opinion on whether one crushes the other or both are somewhat equal. I got Ps3 by the way.